South Sudan is not South Africa. Thabo Mbeki and Mahmood Mamdani argue in their recent NY Times article[1] that courts can't end civil wars. No doubt on their own they cannot, but justice is a critical component for long-term peace.
Peace is more than the end of war, and courts are often an essential element in bringing about peace. Using the examples of post-conflict settlements in South Africa (1990s), Mozambique (1992), and Uganda (1986), Mbeki and Mamdani argue that "Big Tent" political settlements, which bring all combatant parties - whatever their role may have been in mass violence - into the mainstream of participatory democracy, are superior to criminal trials.
This approach however prioritizes short-term stability over long-term justice and sustainable peace. Stability without justice is merely a pause in conflict.
Mbeki and Mandani's South African cure for South Sudan's civil conflict is not just out of place, it is out of time. While history can provide an important context, the current crisis in South Sudan has less in common with its predecessors on the continent (and elsewhere in the world) than meets the eye.
Each breakdown has its own dynamic causes. Applying the same approaches, time and time again is illogical; especially considering the spectacular record of failure as in South Sudan/Sudan.
Demands for accountability might have torpedoed previous settlements in the decades-long conflicts within Sudan and South Sudan. In the current case, however, direct accusations of criminality are a core element and catalyst of the conflict so courts of some kind have to be a part of the end game.
The army has already charged[2] approximately 20 soldiers for crimes of targeting civilians in Juba during operations against rebel forces. So there is already acceptance and scope for the use of courts.
If the fledgling government is attempting to assert itself without being able to defend against threats to the state, any state building process will undoubtedly fail, further guaranteeing long-term instability and no peace.
Not that it is acceptable for a government to act outside of the law and its own institutions no matter how youthful. That is why any court would have to be a part of a show of judicial independence and not just show trials to bolter Presidential authoritarian control.
References
- ^ recent NY Times article (www.nytimes.com)
- ^ charged (www.theepochtimes.com)
Source http://allafrica.com/stories/201402201131.html
Newer articles:
- New fighting in South Sudan threatens oil state capital - 20/02/2014 19:23
- South Sudan rivals trade blame for new atrocities - 20/02/2014 16:38
- South Sudan oil state capital divided, crude output down - 20/02/2014 13:54
- Even China has second thoughts on South Sudan after violence - 20/02/2014 13:08
- South Sudan oil state capital divided, says government - 20/02/2014 11:50
Older news items
- South Sudan Denies Losing ‘Malakal Town’ to Rebels - 19/02/2014 21:09
- UN trapped inside base due to South Sudan fighting - 19/02/2014 14:45
- South Sudan rebels attack key oil town leaving ceasefire in tatters - 19/02/2014 09:34
- South Sudan says contact lost with key town - 19/02/2014 08:42
- South Sudan's tale of two cities: hidden horrors in bustling capital - 19/02/2014 07:08
Latest news items (all categories):
- Research - Europe between a new world war and geopolitical defeat: strategic energy miscalculations, geopolitical ambitions and American pragmatism - 21/11/2026 00:54
- APEC is finding ways to make cross-border services easier - 21/11/2026 00:45
- Xi Jinping’s push for tech independence: How China is trying to close the gap - 21/11/2026 00:44
- How does regional integrated development become a key driver for rapid growth? - 21/11/2026 00:36
- South Sudan rejects claims US-deported migrants face hunger, poor conditions - 21/11/2026 00:12
Random articles (all categories):
- John Deere expands its construction equipment line-up to 18 African countries including South Sudan - 24/03/2021 02:57
- South Sudan protest against UN after weapons found - 10/03/2014 15:48
- Indian peacekeepers in Sudan awarded UN medal - 17/10/2017 01:27
- 'Ecocide': How war and climate change are often linked - 07/12/2023 00:55
- Ethiopia opens new South Sudanese refugee camp to ease congestion - 27/07/2017 07:55
Popular articles:
- Who is the darkest person in the world, according to Guinness World Record? - 25/10/2022 02:34 - Read 151942 times
- School exam results in South Sudan show decline - 01/04/2012 17:58 - Read 28600 times
- Top 10 weakest currency exchange rates in Africa in 2023 - 19/07/2023 00:24 - Read 25689 times
- No oil in troubled waters - 25/03/2014 15:02 - Read 24865 times
- NDSU student from South Sudan receives scholarship - In-Forum - 29/09/2012 01:44 - Read 22852 times