(withinnigeria.com)
What astonishes me most about secession and self determination as controversial topics is the fact that virtually all countries of the world have threats or agitations for secession, it doesn’t matter whether the country is economically prosperous or not. The fundamental reason why it remains one of the most controversial subjects in domestic and international laws. The case of Nigeria being a very peculiar one.
How complex is the definition of self determination and secession?
Article 1 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR) and the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights 1966(ICESR) recognize right to “self determination”.
General Assembly resolutions of United Nations have acknowledged that “all people have the right to self-determination” but with a tricky exception stating that “any attempt aimed at the partial or total disruption of the national unity and the territorial integrity of a country is incompatible with the purposes and principles of the Charter of the United Nations”.
Categorically, the general principle of self determination affirms the right of a people to pursue their political, cultural and economic wishes without the interference or coercion of “outside states”. This principle was the most applicable to colonies seeking independence from imperialists/colonialists
Furthermore, it can be inferred that there is no universal consensus on secession and the only explicit consensus is on self determination which Antonio Cassese argues that the two cannot be the same. Infact, the Vienna declaration of 1993 and friendly relations declaration of 1970 explicitly excludes unlimited right to secession despite recognition for self determination. And in a situation, where international law conflicts with domestic law, the domestic law prevails in most states.
Evaluating cases of successful and unsuccessful seceding states.
As acknowledged above, virtually all countries in the world have secessionist attempts be it soft or radical attempt. We will examining how different standards have been applied by international bodies and United Nations[1] in recognizing and not recognizing states seceding from “parent states”.
The first and most successful case of “unilateral secession” is the case of Bangladesh formerly East Pakistan. After successful seperation of Pakistan from India in 1947, the Eastern part of Pakistan (Bengali) successfully seceded in 1971 unilaterally and was able to escape a lengthy civil war by smartly gaining support of 100 states in General Assembly.
On the other hand, Security Council did not recognize the secession of Katanga from Republic of Congo and infact declared unilateral secession illegal. Similarly, the UN and the then Organisation of African Unity categorically rejected the Biafran Independence, a seceding part of Nigeria in 1967. It gets more complex and tricky when one studies the “balkanization” of old Soviet states like Ukraine, Slovakia, Estonia, Lithuania, Latvia, Belarus etc.
Importantly, the further balkanization of these USSR states has added more complexities to the subject of secession under international law. In some quarters, the balkanization of old Soviet states has been categorized as “dissolution of federation” rather than secession. For example, Serbian population of Bosnia and Srpska Republic have not been recognized as independent states despite recognition of other old Soviet states.
The case of South Sudan seceding successfully from Sudan and Eritrea successfully seceding from Ethiopia are recent successful secessions in Africa but one will be more confused with the refusal of recognition for Somaliland, an independent part of Somalia which has been more stable and has virtually complied with “Montevideo state requirements”.
The case of EU recognizing successfully seceding Republic of Ireland from UK but refusing Catalonia’s secession from Spain despite agitations for over 70 years. In Asia, Taiwan despite complying with Montevideo State Requirements have also not gained supports of major member states and still rated as part of Chinese territory. Kashmir in India has been unsuccessful in seceding from India despite years of agitations. The complex case of Kurds in Iraq and Turkey is also very relevant.
Sanctity of state sovereignty and the Nigerian reality
The sanctity of state sovereignty is not only peculiar to Nigeria, it is a value that will be jealously protected by countries of the world. Section 2(1) of 1999 constitution of Federal Republic of Nigeria states thus ” Nigeria is one indivisible and indissoluble Sovereign State to be known by the name of the Federal Republic of Nigeria.” Section 37 of the Criminal Code provides for elements of what constitutes the offense of “treason”. This is to nullify opinions stating that Nigeria’s constitution is silent on “secession”. Similarly, the notable American case of Texas VS White also affirms the sanctity and indissolubility of American statehood coupled with 14th amendment of America’s constitution explicitly providing for nullification of Lawmakers that might have aided or participated in insurrection against the State. Albeit, Every elected president or Governor in Nigeria is under fundamental obligation of upholding the sovereignty of Nigeria.
In conclusion, the absence of secession clause in the Nigerian constitution is not only peculiar to Nigeria as we have seen countries with such provisions and countries without such provisions. Reasons why international law and some domestic laws have been tricky about secession is to avoid validation for State disruptions. Hence, the agitations for secession or self determination in Nigeria have been largely built on emotions and less understanding of the dynamics. It is my opinion that Nigeria should learn from prosperous countries that have used economic advantages and political inclusion to strengthen statehood as this is the most progressive and strategic. However, agitations for secession in Nigeria will naturally not be accomodated and such agitations should be channelled to referendum and strategic alliance learning from the case of Quebec.
Mujib Dada-Qadri ESQ
References
- ^ United Nations (www.withinnigeria.com)
Newer articles:
- South Sudan: Flooding Kills 7 in South Sudan's Unity State, Official Says - 02/08/2021 23:29
- South Sudan swears in new parliament vowed under peace deal - 02/08/2021 11:16
- Cecafa Kagame Cup: Express lock horns with South Sudan's Atlabara - 02/08/2021 07:22
- Thai engineers support displaced communities in South Sudan by training them on sustainable farming practices - 02/08/2021 06:09
- South Sudan bishops request role in country’s peace negotiations - 02/08/2021 00:41
Older news items
- Tokyo Olympics: South Sudan's Abraham Guem and his race for peace - 01/08/2021 17:18
- 2022 Designated As Year Of Artist Mohammad Wardi - 01/08/2021 16:11
- Peace monitor decries delay on unified forces in South Sudan - 01/08/2021 03:48
- East Africa bloc mulls harmonized medicines regulation to improve public health - 01/08/2021 03:23
- Police arrests 3 South Sudanese nationals for illegal entry - 31/07/2021 01:04
Latest news items (all categories):
- Hope for Christmas gift as South Sudan talks return to Nairobi - 05/12/2024 10:26
- Chinese medical team brings relief to South Sudan patients - 05/12/2024 10:18
- Sudanese bishop speaks about being brutalized by soldiers - 05/12/2024 10:08
- President Biden: Absent Principles - No Honoring Words - Broken Promises - 05/12/2024 09:55
- South Sudan’s ‘Game Of Thrones’ Continues – Analysis - 01/12/2024 17:47
Random articles (all categories):
- South Sudan: ‘No Alternative to Silencing the Guns,’ - 23/11/2014 04:49
- RSS a Rotten Society Mismanaging Itself into Self destruction? - 13/03/2013 10:37
- S. Sudan weekend road ambush leaves 21 dead: police - 10/10/2016 10:31
- South Sudan accuses Sudan of $815m oil theft - 23/01/2012 15:40
- Food insecure South Sudan banks on oil money for agriculture - 07/01/2020 07:35
Popular articles:
- Who is the darkest person in the world, according to Guinness World Record? - 25/10/2022 02:34 - Read 58635 times
- No oil in troubled waters - 25/03/2014 15:02 - Read 22221 times
- School exam results in South Sudan show decline - 01/04/2012 17:58 - Read 21370 times
- NDSU student from South Sudan receives scholarship - In-Forum - 29/09/2012 01:44 - Read 18901 times
- Top 10 weakest currency exchange rates in Africa in 2023 - 19/07/2023 00:24 - Read 18050 times