Thanks for Abu Deng and the forum for bringing to my attention Hon. Timothy Tot's statement to SRS. Let me first quote Article 170(4) of the Interim Constitution of Southern Sudan 2005, on the removal of the Governor of a State. Quote:
170 (4) (a) The state legislature may, in accordance with the state constitution,
pass a vote of no confidence in the Governor
by three quarters majority of all its members;
(b) Should the state legislature pass a vote of no confidence as stated in
paragraph (a) above, the President of the Government of Southern
Sudan shall make a request to the President of the Republic calling for
snap elections of the Governor. The President of the Republic shall act
upon such a request and shall call the state electorate for snap elections
of the Governor to be conducted within sixty days;
(c) The Governor elected in the snap elections shall serve for the
remainder of the original tenure;
(d) Should the Governor who was subjected to the vote of no-confidence
be re-elected, the state legislature shall be deemed to have been
dissolved. A new state legislature shall be elected within sixty days to
complete the tenure of the dissolved legislature; and
(e) A vote of no confidence in the Governor shall not be passed before he
or she completes twelve months in office.
Unquote.
This is a well thought of and delicate balance of powers between the legislature and the executive in which, if there arises a crisis between them, the final arbiter is the people of the State who elected both the Governor and the State legislative Assembly. According to this provision, if the Governor is seen not to deliver, and in the view of the drafters (sub-section (e) above) you need about a year to be able objectively to determine that, the State Legislatively Assembly may remove the Governor by three quarters majority of all its members. Then, the matter goes back to the people (sub-section (b) above) to decide whether the SLA was right (in this case, the removed Governor would not be re-elected) or the Governor was right (and in this case, he gets re-elected) and as a result the SLA is dissolved (sub-section (d) above).
This article provides for a democratic method for settling disputes between the Governor and the SLA which maintains the power of the people of the State in deciding who rules them without intervention from outside the State. This is federalism par excellence.
This provision should have been maintained in the transitional constitution, with sub-section (b), for the sake of relevance, to be rewritten as follows:
(b) Should the state legislature pass a vote of no confidence as stated in paragraph (a) above, the President of the Republic shall call the state electorate for snap elections of the Governor to be conducted within sixty days.
Therefore, there was no shortage of constitutional mechanisms to settle disputes within a state in the ICSS. The only explanation for the new provisions in the Transitional Constitution is to be found in wanting to concentrate powers in the hands of the President at the expense of federalism that Southerners fought for since early 1950s. The question that imposes itself is: who determines whether there is "a crisis in a state that threatens national security and territorial integrity", which is given as the condition for dismissing the Governor or dissolving the state assembly? Of course, if there was a situation like that the President of the Republic would declare a state of emergency in that particular state in accordance with the article on the declaration of the state of emergency. So, the argument does not hold water. For sure, it is not true that a State Governor is elected with the consent of the President, as Hon. Tot asserts.
If what Hon. Timothy Tot says, that the article will not be applied, then why all this insistence from the President of GoSS to pass it without amendment?
Nobody will convince anybody that an elected Governor or SLA can be got rid of without involving the electorate who elected them in the first place, and you still talk of democracy and federal system.
Powers Of President In Draft Transitional Constitution Conditional
9 June 2011-(Juba) -Members of parliament mandated to study the draft transitional constitution say the powers of the president to relieve governors are conditional.
The chairperson of the executive and legislative cluster said that the president can relieve a state governor only when there is a crisis in the state that undermines national security.
Timothy Tot Chol spoke to SRS on Thursday in Juba.
[Timothy Chol] - "We found that in the interim period, from 2005 until now, some governors sometimes misuse these powers to the disadvantage of people of that state. There were quarrels; there were disagreements which sometimes led to lack of stability in some states. Now, it was thought by the drafters of the interim constitution that there must be a power above the states and governors who can intervene in the event of any quarrel in a state. By the way, those quarrels could even jeopardize the tranquility and the harmony and even the national security of the new republic unless there is a super power which can intervene."
Article 101 (R) of the draft transitional constitution says that the president has the powers to remove a state governor, and/or dissolve the state legislative assembly in the event of a crisis in a state that threatens national security and territorial integrity.
Mister Tut said the president cannot exercise this power unnecessarily.
[Timothy Chol]:"It is a conditional power which is rarely or which will be rarely used, you see. Unless there is this situation or this situation arises where the national integrity and national security is being threatened, I don't think the president can exercise such a power. So there is unjustified fear that the president may use it to get of the people he does not like. But I don't think it can happen because in the first place, the governors are elected by the people with the consent of the president himself."
Mister Tot said the constitution does not specify whether a state governor relieved by the president could contest in elections.
He however said that logically, a governor, when relieved under such circumstances could not contest anymore.
Newer articles:
- South Sudanese are Hostage within UNMIS camp Kadugli/Sudan sector VI - 16/06/2011 01:00
- If Kiir is the Boss of GoSS he Should Fire Dr. Riek Machar - 14/06/2011 01:00
- The Creatures that are not allow to be killed illegally according to the Collo Tradition - 14/06/2011 01:00
- Don't Give the President Absolute Power!!! - 11/06/2011 01:00
- Are we aware about the coming period? - 11/06/2011 01:00
Older news items
- South Sudan needs to improve its accountability - 10/06/2011 01:00
- Abyei Crisis should be a Wakeup Call - 08/06/2011 01:00
- Speech delivered by the SPLM-DC Chairman Dr Lam Akol, on the second anniversary of the party (Including Arabic Translation) - 08/06/2011 01:00
- A Letter to the Chollo People - 05/06/2011 01:00
- South- Sudan, Peace the Priority - 03/06/2011 01:00
Latest news items (all categories):
- UNDP and the Office of the Vice President Launches the Women and Youth Leadership Program in South Sudan - 14/02/2025 11:37
- The Grave Blunders And The Paradoxical Ways In Leadership Sector - 14/02/2025 11:32
- ADF approves $153.66 million for Uganda-South Sudan electricity interconnection project - 13/02/2025 20:48
- Rwandan peacekeepers in South Sudan get UN service medals for their service - 13/02/2025 20:44
- Afreximbank seeks to claw back US$657mn debt from South Sudan - 13/02/2025 20:30
Random articles (all categories):
- Where is South Sudan, what did Tom Hiddleston say in his Golden Globes acceptance speech and what is a ‘white saviour’ complex? - 10/01/2017 00:59
- South Sudan least safe country in Africa - survey - 15/06/2018 00:16
- Sudan police fire tear gas as organisers call nationwide protests - 11/01/2019 16:19
- S.Sudan rivals blocking aid to famine-risk zones: US, EU - 30/10/2015 12:06
- Generous €12,400 raised to support Mary Ellen McGroarty’s work in South Sudan - 29/07/2024 19:02
Popular articles:
- The Final Communique of SPLM-DC Third Session of the National Council - 29/03/2011 01:00 - Read 76198 times
- Roles and Definition of Political Parties - 29/04/2011 01:00 - Read 61274 times
- Agriculture in Southern Sudan: Challenges and Investment Opportunities - 06/10/2010 01:45 - Read 42383 times
- Fashoda Youth Forum Rehabilitation of Drainage Culverts in Malakal town Report - 07/08/2008 16:22 - Read 33697 times
- Dozens of gunmen on horseback ambush peacekeepers - 24/05/2008 13:47 - Read 26840 times