Andrew Bogrand is a senior communications and outreach officer at Democracy International.
Charged with raping five foreign aid workers and killing their colleague last summer, soldiers from the South Sudan military are facing their accusers[1] in a closed-door military court this month in Juba. The alleged attack, and the government of South Sudan’s questionable response, received widespread condemnation. Given the high visibility of the case, the soldiers are not the only ones facing trial. In the world’s newest country, the government’s ability to administer justice is also being judged.
Unfortunately, while the fate of the soldiers is unclear, the verdict on the government is all but determined. The rule of law is nonexistent in South Sudan and mass rape remains a tool of war[2]. The high degree of international advocacy that motivated the government of South Sudan to convene the military court, including pressure[3] from Rep. Christopher H. Smith (R-N.J.), has not created a process to ensure justice for South Sudanese victims. There is no serious political will, let alone resources, to resolve their cases. The court is little more than a show trial for Western governments.
But not all endeavors to deliver justice in South Sudan are a “sham[4],” as the South Sudan Human Rights Observatory has referred to the case of the soldiers. Ironically, one of the more legitimate efforts involves a troupe of South Sudanese playwrights who administer their own mock trials. Their work should be instructive in the search for peace.
The troupe, a Shakespearean theater company that achieved minor fame in London[5], has transformed itself into a roving citizen forum where participants air grievances, host mock trials and share potential ideas for reparations. The forums are immensely popular, especially in South Sudan’s remote villages. Their efforts are supported by other remarkable grass-roots organizations, including a youth network[6] of 200 trained volunteers, who collect testimonies and provide grief counseling across the country. While the military court has earned more media attention, these playwrights, artists and activists are working behind the scenes to get to the fundamental challenges of life and justice in a failed state.
By most accounts, the strikingly inhumane[7] levels of violence in South Sudan render useless any restorative model of forward-looking reconciliation, such as those employed in South Africa[8]. At this point, justice — or, at least, the hope for an end to the impunity — has become a prerequisite for peace. This is evidenced by the popularity of the mock trials and public forums: There are no formally trained judges in the audience, and participants presumably know that the perpetrators are unlikely to ever face prosecution. Yet, victims still share their stories.
It might be the case that self-expression is more cathartic than any courtroom ritual. This is partly the rationale behind the Russian rights group Memorial, which focuses on recording abuses[9] under the Soviet Union, and the work of a forensics organization collecting testimonies[10] from the Guatemalan genocide. At the very least, some victims in South Sudan are finding a way forward through public testimony that is uniquely South Sudanese, even if the efforts are guided by Shakespearean actors.
Of course, South Sudan’s nascent civil society is woefully unequipped to fully address the scope of abuse or prevent the country’s downward trajectory alone. The pool of victims is essentially endless and efforts to monitor human rights abuses are inhibited by ongoing fighting and an increasingly paranoid government. Public forums are rudimentary and risk dissolving into mob justice.
But the international community could better support these imperfect efforts. While many local activists have fled, those that remain could use better training and more robust protection when they discuss and expose violations. Donor organizations should consider repurposing funds allocated for implementing the stillborn 2015 peace agreement[11] into support for public forums, hearings and domestic human rights research. And the South Sudan “troika” — comprising the U.S., United Kingdom and Norwegian governments — should use their considerable leverage to push for war crimes documentation, including through regional bodies.
It is past time to change course in South Sudan. Instead of the international community’s current approach of heavy-handed idealism, the country needs a rights-based transitional justice strategy informed by South Sudanese citizens. It will eventually require institutional reform, a peace accord and an effective justice system, none of which are currently on the horizon. But for now, any hope for progress involves space for testimonies, hearings and self-expression — even if delivered through trials without consequence.
References
- ^ are facing their accusers (www.washingtonpost.com)
- ^ mass rape remains a tool of war (www.nytimes.com)
- ^ pressure (www.newsweek.com)
- ^ sham (www.reuters.com)
- ^ minor fame in London (www.theglobeandmail.com)
- ^ youth network (scymisouthsudan.org)
- ^ strikingly inhumane (www.amnesty.org)
- ^ South Africa (www.bbc.com)
- ^ recording abuses (www.economist.com)
- ^ collecting testimonies (sfi.usc.edu)
- ^ 2015 peace agreement (www.aljazeera.com)
Newer articles:
- U.N. moves to protect South Sudan civilians after years of criticism - 28/08/2017 01:36
- South Sudan should investigate death of U.S. reporter: rights group - 27/08/2017 11:34
- American journalist killed during fighting in South Sudan after embedding with the rebels for the past week - 27/08/2017 11:01
- American killed in civil war-torn South Sudan was 'caught in fighting,' army says - 26/08/2017 13:36
- Little progress two years after South Sudan peace deal - 25/08/2017 20:12
Older news items
- South Sudan regrets monitor's negative assessment on peace progress - 25/08/2017 10:33
- UN calls on S. Sudan to stop impeding its peacekeepers - 24/08/2017 17:13
- South Sudan's leaders bear 'direct responsibility' for conflict, UN Security Council told - 24/08/2017 13:53
- South Sudan President Salva Kiir downplays refugee crisis - 24/08/2017 11:33
- 24 MSF Facilities Damaged, Looted in South Sudan - 24/08/2017 09:55
Latest news items (all categories):
- South Sudan needs ‘civic education’ before elections, says bishop - 16/01/2025 16:42
- South Sudan parties set to resume peace talks in Kenya - 16/01/2025 16:39
- Abandoned but not forgotten – the invisible crisis in South Sudan - 16/01/2025 16:35
- The SAF has committed barbaric atrocities against South Sudanese refugees in Wad Medani - 16/01/2025 16:27
- Syria 2025: The historical Syrian project: From revolution to a modern inclusive civil state - 16/01/2025 16:10
Random articles (all categories):
- RSF victories in Darfur strengthen its hand in Sudan peace talks, experts say - 03/11/2023 03:59
- South Sudan vaccinates 947 health workers against COVID-19 - 13/04/2021 08:17
- Missed Opportunity in South Sudan - 01/10/2016 15:10
- U.N. urges peacekeepers to redeploy to focus on South Sudan hot spots - 11/07/2013 16:18
- South Sudan Violence Forces Tens Of Thousands To Flee - 03/01/2012 19:15
Popular articles:
- Who is the darkest person in the world, according to Guinness World Record? - 25/10/2022 02:34 - Read 61547 times
- No oil in troubled waters - 25/03/2014 15:02 - Read 22304 times
- School exam results in South Sudan show decline - 01/04/2012 17:58 - Read 21490 times
- NDSU student from South Sudan receives scholarship - In-Forum - 29/09/2012 01:44 - Read 19052 times
- Top 10 weakest currency exchange rates in Africa in 2023 - 19/07/2023 00:24 - Read 18779 times