The Monitor (Kampala)
Posted to the web 17 August 2007
By Angelo Izama, Paul Harera & Hussien Bogere

john Garang

THE ghost of John Garang is back to haunt Sudanese and regional politics, this time around with a bold declaration from Khartoum that the South Sudan leader was assassinated.

In an interview with the Sudanese Arab-language daily Akhbar Alyoum, an English translation of which was published online at www.newsudanvision.com on August 14, the Sudanese State Minister of Interior Aleu Ayeny Aleu suggests that the helicopter crash that killed Garang in July 2005 was an orchestrated murder plot and not an accident as the final investigation report claimed.

Mr Aleu also claims that Garang did not die in President Museveni's official helicopter but that he had switched aircraft at Entebbe on his way back to Sudan. He claims the fallen founder of the Sudan Peoples Liberation Movement/Army used a military chopper which then crashed due to bad weather and questionable piloting.

This is not the first time Garang's death is being attributed to foul play but is part of a growing appeal in South Sudan for a criminal investigation to be opened into Garang's death.

Until now the accepted version of the death was that Garang died after President Museveni's helicopter crashed with him on board following a meeting that the two held at the latter's country home in Rwakitura in western Uganda. All 13 people on board perished.

The interior minister, however, claims that a conspiracy of silence kept the real truth from the public. Yesterday, the Uganda government spokesman Kirunda Kivejinja said, "[Aleu] should tell us who murdered [Garang] so that we know."

He added that if Mr Aleu knows of a better method of discovering the truth he should come forward.

Mr Aleu was a member of the Sudanese group that was part of the international team that investigated the crash. Uganda was also represented on the team that had experts from the United States.

According to him, Garang was asked by Mr Bakri Hassan Saleh, the Sudanese presidential affairs minister, to use the official presidential plane for his flight to Uganda.

Mr Aleu claims the organisers of Garang's meeting, which included the Ugandan government and "three western ambassadors", convinced the Sudan establishment that they would provide him with transportation. He did not name the ambassadors.

One of the questions heavily debated in the aftermath of the helicopter crash, which also claimed the lives of the Ugandan crew and Garang's guards, is why the president of South Sudan and also first vice president of Sudan, did not fly an official aircraft as protocol requires. No explanation has been offered. He was just weeks old as Sudanese VP when he died.

Mr Aleu says that while the international report into Garang's death cited pilot error as the main reason for the helicopter crash, in truth matters were far worse.

"The information that was presented to our committee indicates that the pilot [Col. Peter Nyakairu] was previously demoted from his military ranks one day before piloting the plane carrying Dr. John Garang," Mr Aleu told the paper.

He says the committee, however, did not look into the circumstances under which Nyakairu had been allegedly demoted but instead says there was evidence that he was at odds with his flight crew. For example, the pilot allegedly disagreed with his crew after the helicopter was airborne.

Public information, however, shows that Nyakairu was not demoted but promoted well before the tragedy, a fact that could cast doubt on some of Mr Aleu's allegations.

That Mr Aleu is claiming foul play is not new. President Museveni first cast doubt on the accident theory just days after the fatal crash. He said he could not rule out the role of "external factors".

Last year, when a Shs7 billion cheque from the National Insurance Corporation was paid out as compensation money to the government, sources close to the presidency told this newspaper that Mr Museveni was still unconvinced that his comrade Garang died as a result of an accident.

President Museveni and Garang first met as politically inclined students in the late 1960s at the University of Dar es Salaam. Some of Mr Aleu's allegations have a familiar ring. He claims in the interview that the helicopter was not airworthy adding that some Ugandan security agents were inexplicably on board.

His other claims are, however, fresh and cast a long shadow on Garang's death. Mr Aleu claims that the real presidential chopper was switched with another plane which explains the poor condition of the helicopter that crashed.

According to him, when parts of the helicopter were examined by analysts in Moscow it was discovered that the aircraft's designations did not match those of the presidential chopper.

"We found out that the machine numbers were not compatible with the so-called presidential number and that number AF, 605 differs from the presidential number's main rotor burp 8-1930-000821-5387," he says.

According to Mr Aleu, the pilot's assistant, in a recorded conversation during the flight, seemed unsure of the plane's details. "Sometimes he said UK747 [instead of UK757]. The other plane was holding number ATCO-AF-605118:2. The plane that had crashed does not hold number 096112 (1997 Russian 02/07/05)".

Mr Aleu claims that the chopper that crashed belonged to the Ugandan military and that when this alleged fact came to light some on his committee limited the investigation to "mechanical failure". He said when he attempted to verify the identity of the "two helicopters", he was blocked by Kampala. "Ugandan authorities refused to allow me to look at the grounded plane [at Entebbe] which was the presidential chopper," he told Akhbar Alyoum.

Not long ago, Ms Rebecca Nyandeng, Garang's widow, claimed her husband was a victim of a murder plot.

"At the back of my mind, I knew my husband was assassinated," Ms Nyandeng said in an interview in Nairobi.

She did not name the assassins. Daily Monitor could not reach her on phone by press time. An assistant said she was in South Africa for treatment. Neither could we reach Mr Lam Akol, a southern Sudanese who is the foreign minister of Sudan in power-sharing deal with SPLM/A.

Officially, the South Sudan government has accepted the conclusion that it was pilot error that led to Garang's death.

Mr Ali Sadiq, Khartoum's foreign affairs ministry spokesperson, yesterday declined to comment on Mr Aleu's claims.

In an interview with the Daily Nation about Ms Nyandeng's claims of assassination, President Salva Kiir of South Sudan said that he was satisfied with the final report by investigators.

"I was with her when the report was presented but she did not raise any of the statements she is now making," Mr Kiir said.

In a recent reshuffle, Mr Kiir dropped Ms Nyandeng as minister and retained her only as an advisor. Two years after Garang's death, Mr Aleu suggests his ghost will only rest with an international criminal investigation. "Garang was killed by people who he thought were his friends," Mr Aleu concluded. Mr John Nasasira, the minister of works and transport who also chaired the crash investigation committee, cast doubt on the credibility of the Arabic paper interview.

"I do not know if the minister was interviewed or even quoted rightly ," he said yesterday.

Dr John Garang de Mabior's death led to riots in South Sudanese towns where he was a hero to many.

Please login to comment

People in this conversation

  • Guest - Mithijwok

    We have heard so many accusation against Uganda Government and Khartoum NIF Extremists for their foul play for the death of our leader late Dr.John Garang. But we have not ask ourselves as Junubians about whether some people who have a potential interests for leadership within the SPLM's leadership may have foul play in the death our leader. I raised this question because the widow of Dr. John Garang made it categorical that her husband was assassinated without mentioning those who assassinated our leader Dr. John Garang. None of the SPLM official said nothing for her accusations. Many of us have become doubtful about the SPLM's stand for the death of our late leader. I'm not sure what made Salva Kiir to decide to fire Mr. Aleu Ayeny Aleu for his remarks but when Rebecca Nyadeing made her accusation last time none of SPLM official said none. The big question we should ask ourselves as Junubians is: Who real kill our late leader Dr.John Garang, is it Uganda Government and its foreign ally, Khartoum NIF extremists or Junubians because it could be possible that Junubians may have been involved in the death of our late leader Dr. John Garang? We all admire our late leader Dr. John Garang and we would like to know who is behind the death of our late leader.

    0 Like
  • Guest - James Okuk

    I think Mithjwok is going very far and not being fair to accuse Southerners (Junubin) for the death of Garang. What interest does any Southerner has for doing that when it is obvious that none of them could be the same as late beloved Dr. Garang? I tend to agree with the detailed investigative theory of H.E Aleu Ayieny that some elements in the Ugandan army might have played a game with an advanced country to do that evil act. I tend to disagree with the vague theory of the widow, Hon. Rebecca Nyandeng that she knows who assassinated her husband but would not mention them because she want to preserve unity of the South. The recommendation of H.E. Aleu that a fresh criminal investigation commitee be formed, using the clues which he found, is something the President of the Sudan and President of Goss should not ignore. In fact I would rather recommend that H.E. Aleu be made the head of that committee and we shall get the truth because he is a well-trained cadre for such kinds of investigations and he has credible experience in criminology. Suspending him, according to the motion of SPLM Secretary-General would generate more suspicions, and perhaps disquite.

    0 Like
  • Guest - Makoi Majakdit

    Why were all these accusations brought when Salva Kiir fired Riek Machar and Nyandeng Chol? I never heard these before and I will not believe any because they're just made up to taint the image of leaders like Salva Kiir Mayardit. Those who brought this issue up were or either agents of Dr Riek Machar - the vampire who delights in the death of little children and the elderly.
    Whatever you say, everybody knows Garand death was not a foul play, if it was, it could possibly come from Riek Machar because he was third in-power and needs to rise up bit so he could over come any one.
    The fighting in South Sudan could claim a very different ladder if you continue to stir it. It's not good for your health!

    0 Like