President Kiir Should Remove Army Officers From National Anthem Committee
- Details
- Created on Sunday, 15 August 2010 17:58
- Written by Gordon Buay Reath
The news that came out of Juba that SPLA military officers were permitted by the SPLA C-in-C to "lead and facilitate" the formation of the committee for South Sudan National Anthem disturbed the conscience of South Sudan intelligentsia. So many intellectuals began to question the wisdom of giving military officers the license to interfere into politics in violation of strict separation between the armed forces and politics imposed by the Interim Constitution of South Sudan.
These officers, who came up with the idea of the national anthem, did not get any resistance from the President of the Government of South Sudan who should have advised them to mind their military business. If any idea from military officers is to be entertained even if political, then, the military officers may one day stop South Sudan Legislative Assembly from discussing a controversial issue involving the army.
In addition to their interference into politics, the sad part of the saga surrounding the national anthem is that these military officers, who are not academic experts, came up with the title "Land of Cush" to be the national anthem of South Sudan. There are no more titles offered except the "Land of Cush". Neither Maj. Gen. Kuol Deim Kuol nor Col. Malaak Ayuen (the two officers who came up with the idea) is biblical historian who can intellectually defend whether the tribes of the South are the only people in the Horn of Africa who are Cushitic. The biblical scholars already concluded that Cush is referred to Bejas, Oromos of Ethiopia, Somalis and South Sudanese.
The question in the minds of so many educated Southerners is that if the people of South Sudan are not the only people in Africa who are Cushitic, why would these officers title our anthem as "Land of Cush"? One of the tragedies we are facing in South Sudan is that an officer who is not academically an expert in a certain field would claim some knowledge about a certain field. People should remember when late Dr. John Garang made a proposition that Lol in Rumbek could be a Garden of Eden. One could argue that Dr. Garang was using Good News Bible for political propaganda because he was not an expert in the field who should be taken serious. But there are some officers in the SPLA who believe everything Garang said about the creation of human beings because these officers lacked education to conduct more research whether what Garang alleged was a mere propaganda or academic truth that may be authenticated by the experts in biblical history. These officers did not even ask Dr. Garang to provide his academic references to support his propositions either out of ignorance or fear.
The idea behind the title "Land of Cush" originated out of propaganda of Dr. John Garang who used Good News Bible to support his argument for the creation of New Sudan. The problem is that when one reads King James Version, one gets a different interpretation which contradicted Good News Bible John Garang embraced. Because the SPLA officers do not read books on biblical history, they think Dr. John Garang was a religious expert although most educated Southerners know that John Garang was Agro-economist, not biblical historian.
Given the interference of SPLA officers into politics, South Sudan people should come out loudly to condemn such a thing if they want to build a prosperous democratic state in the future. One thing must be clear: If South Sudan will become an independent state, the first obstacle to democratization will come from SPLA officers. The people of the South should clearly understand this. If the people want to create a democratic state in 2011, they should make sure that the SPLA officers are locked in the barracks. South Sudan intelligentsia doesn't get it up to now why Salva Kiir Mayardit allowed Maj. Gen. Kuol Deim Kuol and Col. Malaak Ayuen to interfere into politics without risking court martial. There is no doubt that President Kiir, in his capacity as C-in-C, might have given them permission to interfere into political affairs at the expense of separation of powers principle enshrined in the Interim Constitution of South Sudan.
People may begin to wonder whether South Sudan politicians learned any lesson from other African countries regarding the army. There have been so many coups in the last sixty years in Africa because the army gets involved in politics. Sudan is one example where the army has become a negative force in democratizing the country. Every Sudanese knows how many coups took place in Sudan. If Kiir Mayardit does not see this, people are afraid he will one day be told by the same SPLA officers to resign from his post as C-in-C.
What the C-in-C of the SPLA should do is to impose principle of civilian supremacy over the military on the SPLA army so that the officers begin to learn the strict separation of military from politics. Many SPLA soldiers have been conditioned for more than twenty five years to give no respect to civilian rule. The military supremacy that reigned supreme during the liberation struggle before the conclusion of the CPA is the first enemy of liberal democracy in South Sudan. If the South is to be made secured from SPLA officers, the GOSS must re-educate the soldiers to subject them to civilian rule. People need to take note from Dr. Pavlov’s experiment where he conditioned a dog to change its behavior. As we know that human beings are also animals like dogs, the army must undergo the same experiment of Dr. Pavlov. The SPLA army leadership must institute a process of slow disengagement of military officers from economic, political, and administrative positions of power. Failure to do so would be a recipe for disaster in the long run because most SPLA officers see civilian supremacy over the military as a foreign notion.
In conclusion, it is imperative for President Kiir to remove Maj. Gen. Kuol Deim Kuol and Col. Malaak Ayuen from the National Anthem Committee so as to observe the strict separation of the army from politics. The primary beneficiary of the separation of powers principle is Salva Kiir Mayardit himself because as a President he would not need military officers to stop Council of Ministers meeting on Fridays to impose their will.
The author could be reached at This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.
Newer news items:
- Dr. Lam Akol on Akhbar El Youm platform. - 21/08/2010
- Statement: Chairman, Sudan African National Union (SANU) - 21/08/2010
- SPLM PB is Hoodwinking Southerners: Referendum is Already Postponed - 19/08/2010
- The SPLM Should Have Kept on Worn out Clothes of Our Martyrdom and not Changed their Right Trajectory Paths - 18/08/2010
- Advice to SPLM/A: Accept Postponement of Referendum But With Conditions - 17/08/2010
Older news items:
- South Sudan to deploy 200 highly qualified civil servants from foreign countries - 15/08/2010
- Open letter to President Salva Kiir Mayardit, VP Dr. Riek Machar and SG Pagan Amum - 14/08/2010
- The Disputes to Decide Whether the South Sudan can Vote for Separation or for united with the North. - 12/08/2010
- Salva Kiir to Come Together With Dr. Lam For Refererndum Sake - 11/08/2010
- SPLM-DC Canada Communiqué of Solidarity - 10/08/2010
-
15-08-2010 19:47:38 |Unregistered| Yohannes Kong Tut
Mr. Buay Reath! I gree with you for sure. Cushites are those northern desert tribes such as Beja and all tribes in the further north of Sudan, Oromo in Ethiopia, and all Somalis with exception of Bantu minortiy of Somolia only. The reason why we think we tend to favour Cush is because it is associated to a "people tall and smooth skinned" which dates back to the Babylonian conquest of the region. Current cushitic tribes in Sudan were pushed all the way from middle east by Arab and Semitic tribes Upper Egypt and then they pushed the Nuer, Shilluk and Dinka from Upper Egypt to lower Egypt and Sudan. The whole region of Africa was known as Cush which later became Abyssinia(ancient Sudan). Even "Ethiopia" is the original name of the near ancient Sudan with its capital in Meroe in Upper Sudan closer to Asswan. Cush was adapted as a name for the whole region because of the invading beja and impoverished desert Arab tribes. It should not be the army to create national anthem but it should be people like intellectuals, priests and culturists with deep background of literature. Even Gordon Kong, the nonliterate singer of Gajiok have also tried his best to create a national anthem. How could nonliterate singers attempt to create national anthem without good background of cultural philosophy and history. All nonliterate singers don't know anything except that we appreciate their instrumental beats and all other noisy components of their music. The president will change mind from appointing such personnel with lack of good cultural background to engage in important things. It is not necessarily that national anthem will be sung immediately after independent. No, it can take 2-3 years to compile it before it release to schools and all institutions. Thank you
-
17-08-2010 01:55:25 |Unregistered| Aban kur
These morons have started to fight over uncooked food. This is always the problem with food lovers. Gallant SPLA armies are the ones who will create this would be new country. All top SPLM executives are military men including Kirr. There are many rives to be cross and battles to be fought before we reach or put foot on this promise land. So for this traitor or former militia SSFD Gordon Reath and nephew Yahannes Tut, stop your nonsense. Let those brave freedom fighters finish the work and rest assured we will have a lot of sugar and bread to keep you happy like samll babies from going back to your former masters.No more hunting for food or killing your brothers
Latest News/Articles
Mr. Buay Reath! I gree with you for sure. Cushites are those northern desert tribes such as Beja and all tribes in the further north of Sudan, Oromo in Ethiopia, and all Somalis with exception of Bantu minortiy of Somolia only. The reason why we think we tend to favour Cush is because it is associated to a "people tall and smooth skinned" which dates back to the Babylonian conquest of the region. Current cushitic tribes in Sudan were pushed all the way from middle east by Arab and Semitic tribes Upper Egypt and then they pushed the Nuer, Shilluk and Dinka from Upper Egypt to lower Egypt and Sudan. The whole region of Africa was known as Cush which later became Abyssinia(ancient Sudan). Even "Ethiopia" is the original name of the near ancient Sudan with its capital in Meroe in Upper Sudan closer to Asswan. Cush was adapted as a name for the whole region because of the invading beja and impoverished desert Arab tribes. It should not be the army to create national anthem but it should be people like intellectuals, priests and culturists with deep background of literature. Even Gordon Kong, the nonliterate singer of Gajiok have also tried his best to create a national anthem. How could nonliterate singers attempt to create national anthem without good background of cultural philosophy and history. All nonliterate singers don't know anything except that we appreciate their instrumental beats and all other noisy components of their music. The president will change mind from appointing such personnel with lack of good cultural background to engage in important things. It is not necessarily that national anthem will be sung immediately after independent. No, it can take 2-3 years to compile it before it release to schools and all institutions. Thank you